Where to Find the Best Baked Goods in Nantucket
Nantucket might be known for windswept beaches, cedar-shingled charm, and salty sea air—but let’s be real: it’s also an island filled with seriously good baked goods. Whether you’re strolling to the beach with a sticky bun in hand or hunting for the perfect loaf to go with your sunset picnic, the island’s bakeries are little pockets of flour-dusted heaven. From old-school island staples to creative newcomers, here are 7 bakery spots on Nantucket where everything just tastes better by the sea.
1. Nantucket Bake Shop – A Local Legend Since 1978
Family-owned and deeply loved, Nantucket Bake Shop is one of those places that feels like home—even if it’s your first visit. It’s been part of the island’s rhythm for over four decades, baking up Portuguese bread, flaky pastries, and treats that locals swear by.
Specialty: The Portuguese sweet bread is iconic—soft, slightly sweet, and perfect with a slab of butter. Their almond macaroons and blueberry muffins are top-tier too.
Local Tip: Go early morning and grab a few fresh loaves before the breakfast rush. They freeze beautifully (but probably won’t last that long).
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.7/5 on Google)
📍 Location: 17 Old South Rd, Nantucket, MA
2. Wicked Island Bakery – Your Everyday Craving Spot
The name says it all—Wicked Island Bakery is wicked good. This casual, bustling spot is a local go-to for donuts, breakfast sandwiches, and baked-from-scratch treats that hit the sweet spot every time. It’s unfussy, friendly, and always smells amazing.
Specialty: The sticky buns are legendary—gooey, golden, and rich. The apple fritters and breakfast scones fly off the shelves.
Local Tip: Don’t overlook the savory side—ham & cheese croissants and egg sandwiches are perfect fuel for a beach day.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.6/5 on Google)
📍 Location: 7 Bayberry Ct, Nantucket MA
3. Born & Bread: Mercantile and Bakery – The New Kid With Serious Game
Part bakery, part mercantile, all-around charming—Born & Bread is a newer addition to the island but already a staple. With rustic loaves, buttery croissants, and a curated little market of pantry goods, it’s the kind of place you stop in for bread and walk out with half your vacation grocery list.
Specialty: Try their crusty sourdough or focaccia with seasonal toppings. The chocolate croissant might just ruin you for all others.
Local Tip: Grab a pastry and browse their local goods and picnic-ready treats—perfect for a sunset charcuterie moment.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.8/5 on Google)
📍 Location: 35 Centre St, Nantucket, MA
4. Something Natural – Iconic Sandwiches & Seriously Good Bread
Something Natural is more than a bakery—it’s a full-on island ritual. Tucked along the leafy stretch of Cliff Road, this charming cottage-style spot has been feeding Nantucket locals and visitors since the 1970s. The vibe is easy, breezy, and wonderfully homemade. While most people know it for its giant, build-your-own sandwiches, the real secret is in the bread—baked fresh daily, soft, hearty, and slightly sweet. Whether you’re picnic-bound or just craving a thick slice of Portuguese bread, this place never disappoints.
Specialty: Their Portuguese bread is a classic, but don’t sleep on the herb bread or oatmeal varieties. Add a sandwich with sprouts, avocado, and house-made hummus, and you’re in business.
Local Tip: Grab your sandwich and head to Steps Beach for the ultimate lunch-with-a-view. Pro tip: split one—they’re huge!
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.6/5 on Google)
📍 Location: 50 Cliff Rd, Nantucket, MA
5. 45 Surfside Bakery and Café – Laid-Back Island Vibes
This beachy little gem feels like a friend’s kitchen—casual, colorful, and full of soul. 45 Surfside serves up breakfast, lunch, and amazing baked goods that keep locals coming back week after week.
Specialty: Try their cinnamon rolls, banana bread, and any of their cookies (especially the ginger molasses). Also great for hearty breakfast sandwiches.
Local Tip: Sit on the porch with your treats and enjoy a little quiet before hitting Surfside Beach.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5 on Google)
📍 Location: 45 Surfside Rd, Nantucket, MA
6. Slow to Rise Bakery – Small Batch, Big Heart
Slow to Rise Bakery lives up to its name—everything here is thoughtfully crafted, fermented with care, and made in small batches that let quality shine. Founded by Tucker Puljic and Katrina Newfrock, this island-born bakery started as a passion project and quickly grew into a local favorite for naturally leavened breads, creative cookies, and (yes) really good bagels.
Specialty: Their crusty sourdough and poppy-seed morning buns are crowd favorites, and the rotating cookie flavors are always worth the splurge.
Local Tip: Sign up for their newsletter to stay in the loop on weekly flavors, pre-order windows, and their seasonal retail shop hours. This is one bakery you’ll want to follow closely.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.8/5 on Google)
📍 Location: 1 Cherry St (coming soon!), Nantucket, MA — catch them at the Farmers Market on Saturdays
7. Bartlett's Farm – Fresh Produce & Even Fresher Pastries
Bartlett’s Farm is Nantucket’s largest and oldest family-run farm, and while the produce is top-notch, the bakery counter is pure gold. Tucked inside their market, you’ll find scratch-made muffins, breads, pies, and cookies that reflect the farm’s love for real food and local ingredients.
Specialty: Their pies are summer perfection (hello, strawberry rhubarb), and the morning glory muffins are island-famous.
Local Tip: Get a coffee and pastry and enjoy it outside in the flower field—it’s the most peaceful start to a day on Nantucket.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.6/5 on Google)
📍 Location: 33 Bartlett Farm Rd, Nantucket, MA
Whether you're starting your morning with a strong coffee and croissant or ending your day with a cookie under the stars, Nantucket’s bakeries add a little magic to every bite. This island doesn’t just serve beauty and beaches—it serves seriously good bread.
More from
North American Islands
Category
