Best Places to Eat on Martha's Vineyard: 2025 Insider Picks

Where to Eat on Martha's Vineyard: The Ultimate 2025 Restaurant Guide

From salty harbor breezes to candlelit courtyards, Martha’s Vineyard offers a feast for every kind of traveler. This tiny but mighty island is home to a surprisingly diverse culinary landscape. Whether you're in the mood for fried clams by the dock, award-winning fine dining, or a killer brunch sandwich, Martha’s Vineyard knows how to serve it up.

Here are 15 can’t-miss restaurants that showcase the island’s best bites—from legendary oyster bars to gourmet gems tucked inside historic inns.

‍1. Atria – Elevated American Fare in Edgartown

Nestled inside a stately white colonial home, Atria is where island elegance meets New England charm. This Edgartown staple offers two unique dining experiences: the sophisticated main dining room upstairs and The Brick Cellar downstairs, a cozy gastropub-style lounge. The seasonal menu leans into upscale American cuisine with global touches—think pan-seared scallops, Korean-style short ribs, and their beloved truffle fries. The cocktail list is polished, the wine selection top-tier, and the atmosphere feels celebratory without being stuffy. Perfect for date night, group dinners, or a splurge-worthy evening out.

Specialty: Don’t miss the house-made truffle fries—they’re legendary on the island. If you're there in summer, the local swordfish or halibut dishes are a must-try, often paired with seasonal island-grown vegetables.

Local Tip: Book a table in The Brick Cellar if you're after a more relaxed vibe with the same top-tier food. It’s also a local favorite for late-night bites and has one of the best burger-and-bourbon pairings around.

• Price Range: $$$–$$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.6/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 137 Main Street, Edgartown, MA

2. The Attic – Comfort Food Haven in Vineyard Haven

Perched above the popular Waterside Market, The Attic feels like a secret hideout for foodies in the know. This cozy, second-floor eatery is famous for its decadent mac and cheese, rich with creamy cheese sauce and a crispy baked topping. The fish and chips are some of the best on the island—light, flaky, and golden-fried to perfection. With warm lighting, quirky decor, and a laid-back vibe, it’s a top pick for casual dinners, family meals, or winding down after a day on the water. Bonus: the cocktail menu is creative and surprisingly refined for such a relaxed spot.

Specialty: Their three-cheese baked mac is the stuff of island legend—creamy, gooey, and generously portioned. Pair it with their house fish and chips for the ultimate comfort combo.

Local Tip: Ask for a seat near the windows—you’ll get a quiet view of Main Street below and catch that dreamy Vineyard light at golden hour. Locals swear by the lavender gin fizz, especially after a long beach day.

• Price Range: $$–$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5 on Yelp)
  📍 Location: 82 Main Street, Vineyard Haven, MA

3. 19 Raw Oyster Bar – Sleek Seafood Spot in Edgartown

Just steps from the water in downtown Edgartown, 19 Raw is a haven for oyster aficionados and raw bar fans. With its cool, minimalist interior and patio seating in summer, it strikes the perfect balance between upscale and approachable. The atmosphere is lively, the service polished, and the seafood ultra-fresh. Whether you're grabbing a dozen oysters with bubbly or diving into an elegant seafood tower, 19 Raw serves island luxury on a plate.

Specialty: Start with a chilled platter of local Katama Bay oysters, then explore the menu’s crudo, ceviche, and grilled scallops. Their tuna tartare with yuzu and avocado is another favorite.

Local Tip: Sit at the raw bar for front-row views of the shucking action. Arrive early for a better shot at a walk-in table—it gets packed fast, especially during golden hour.

• Price Range: $$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.6/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 19 Church Street, Edgartown, MA

4. Coop de Ville – Laid-Back Flavors on Oak Bluffs Harbor

Right on the dock in Oak Bluffs, Coop de Ville is the no-frills, high-flavor spot you never knew you needed. Known for its spicy wings and signature seafood bites, it offers dockside dining with a serious side of personality. With picnic tables, cold beers, and harbor views, it’s as Vineyard as it gets—chill, satisfying, and made for kicking back after the beach.

Specialty: The Buffalo wings come in a variety of heat levels and are the stuff of local legend. Add in the stuffed quahogs (seasoned clam stuffing baked in the shell) for a full-flavor island combo.

Local Tip: Go during happy hour and order a local draft beer with your wings—they’ve got one of the best craft beer selections on the island. Sunset from the dockside tables? Pure magic.

• Price Range: $–$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.4/5 on Yelp)
  📍 Location: 12 Circuit Avenue Extension, Oak Bluffs, MA

5. Rockfish – Rustic-Chic Eats in Edgartown

Tucked away in a two-story downtown Edgartown building, Rockfish is a local favorite for its laid-back vibe, rustic decor, and creative small plates. With its brick walls, wood accents, and open kitchen, it feels like an urban loft transplanted to the island. The drink list is stellar, the happy hour generous, and the food consistently hits that sweet spot between casual and elevated.

Specialty: Their wood-fired flatbreads are the go-to—especially the fig and prosciutto or lobster-topped versions. Pair with crispy Brussels sprouts or tuna tartare for a well-balanced meal.

Local Tip: Snag a bar seat upstairs for happy hour specials and people-watching. It's also one of the best spots for a relaxed late lunch when the town crowds die down.

• Price Range: $$–$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 11 North Water Street, Edgartown, MA

6. Bettini – Elegant Island Dining with Lighthouse Views

Inside the luxurious Harbor View Hotel, Bettini is Martha’s Vineyard fine dining at its most photogenic. With sweeping views of Edgartown Lighthouse and an upscale, coastal-modern interior, Bettini is a top-tier choice for celebrations, proposals, or simply treating yourself. The service is white-glove, the ambiance sophisticated, and the food—refined, seasonal, and artfully plated.

Specialty: The lobster risotto is a fan favorite—creamy, rich, and loaded with perfectly cooked lobster. Also try the prime filet or swordfish with a wine pairing from their extensive cellar.

Local Tip: Reserve around sunset and request a window seat—there’s nothing quite like watching the lighthouse glow while sipping a glass of Chablis. Dress smart-casual or better.

• Price Range: $$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 131 North Water Street, Edgartown, MA

7. Bad Martha Farmer's Brewery – Chill Vibes & Craft Beer Deals

For a fun, low-key break from beach hopping, Bad Martha’s is the island’s best brewery hangout. Located in Edgartown’s Vineyard Arts District, it’s part garden party, part beer garden, and always a good time. You’ll find lawn games, picnic tables, and a rotating food truck or snack bar serving up simple, hearty bites.

Specialty: Try the 508 IPA or Martha’s Vineyard Ale, and pair it with a soft pretzel or local sausage dog. When the pizza oven’s going, grab a thin-crust pie and stay a while.

Local Tip: It’s BYOF (bring your own food) friendly if the kitchen’s closed. Swing by in the afternoon for a tasting flight and live music—locals say it’s the island’s best budget-friendly happy hour.

• Price Range: $–$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.6/5 on Yelp)
  📍 Location: 270 Upper Main Street, Edgartown, MA

8. Mo's Lunch – Soulful Comfort Food with Local Flavor

Operating out of the Portuguese-American Club in Oak Bluffs, Mo’s Lunch is the Vineyard’s hidden gem for soulful comfort food. Known for its ever-changing specials and generous portions, Mo’s takes inspiration from Southern and New England roots, turning out crave-worthy plates from a humble kitchen window.

Specialty: The fried chicken sandwich is a crowd-pleaser—crispy, juicy, and stacked with pickles and slaw. Also popular are their BBQ pork plates, smash burgers, and house-made sauces.

Local Tip: Go early—they often sell out of the day's most popular items. Follow them on Instagram for the latest daily specials. And yes, the spicy honey butter is that good.

• Price Range: $–$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.7/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 137 Vineyard Avenue, Oak Bluffs, MA

9. Outermost Inn – Remote Romance & Refined Island Cuisine

Perched on the windswept cliffs of Aquinnah, Outermost Inn offers one of the most romantic and remote dining experiences on the island. Run by the Taylor family (yes, that Taylor family), the vibe is peaceful and elegant, with sweeping views and a prix-fixe menu that celebrates local ingredients and minimalist preparation.

Specialty: Expect changing menus with dishes like dayboat scallops, wild mushroom risotto, and grilled local halibut. Each course is thoughtfully plated and timed.

Local Tip: Make a reservation well in advance—seats are limited, and it books up fast during peak season. Arrive early to walk the grounds and catch the Aquinnah sunset before dinner.

• Price Range: $$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.7/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 81 Lighthouse Road, Aquinnah, MA

10. L’Etoile – Timeless Fine Dining in the Heart of Edgartown

Tucked inside a charming white colonial home just off Water Street, L’Etoile has long been a Martha’s Vineyard institution for romantic dinners and special occasions. The ambiance is cozy and elegant, blending classic French bistro energy with coastal sophistication. With a lush garden patio and candlelit tables inside, this is the spot where food meets atmosphere in the most delicious way.

Specialty: The duck confit is deeply flavorful and perfectly crisped, while the filet mignon with red wine demi-glace is a go-to for meat lovers. Finish with their legendary sticky toffee pudding for dessert.

Local Tip: Reserve an outdoor garden table for the full storybook experience. The wine list is extensive, so don’t be shy about asking for pairing recommendations—they’ll nail it.

• Price Range: $$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.6/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 22 North Water Street, Edgartown, MA

11. 9 Craft Kitchen and Bar – Creative Plates in Vineyard Haven

A rising star in Vineyard Haven’s dining scene, 9 Craft Kitchen and Bar offers an inventive, flavor-packed menu that fuses global flair with local ingredients. The vibe is contemporary rustic with exposed beams, a sleek bar, and warm service that hits the mark. It’s a great spot for a date night, cocktails with friends, or a satisfying solo dinner at the bar.

Specialty: The truffle tots are dangerously addictive, and the Korean short rib tacos are a perfect balance of sweet, salty, and umami. For mains, their rotating fish dish is always worth trying.

Local Tip: Check their specials board—it’s where the kitchen really shows off. Go during off-peak hours to grab a seat without a wait. The spicy cucumber margarita is a local favorite.

• Price Range: $$–$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5 on Yelp)
  📍 Location: 9 Main Street, Vineyard Haven, MA

‍

12. The Seafood Shanty – Edgartown's Classic Waterfront Hangout

With one of the best views in town, The Seafood Shanty is a must for breezy outdoor dining and crowd-pleasing seafood dishes. It’s casual, lively, and the rooftop deck overlooking Edgartown Harbor is the kind of place you’ll want to linger. Perfect for groups, families, or anyone craving fried clams and a cocktail with a view.

Specialty: The lobster roll is a classic, offered both hot with butter or cold with mayo. The fish tacos and clam strips are always a hit, and the frozen drinks are summer in a glass.

Local Tip: Head up to the rooftop early—those seats go fast! For a light lunch, order a raw bar sampler and a frozen mudslide. It's a classic Vineyard combo.

• Price Range: $$–$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.3/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 31 Dock Street, Edgartown, MA

13. Among the Flowers Café – Garden Brunch in Edgartown

Tucked just off the main drag in Edgartown, Among the Flowers Café is a local favorite for charming breakfasts and relaxed brunches. With shaded garden seating, colorful blooms, and a menu packed with crowd-pleasers, this café feels like your friend’s backyard—but with way better pancakes. It's casual, cheerful, and a quintessential Vineyard start to your day.

Specialty: The stuffed French toast—thick slices with cream cheese and berries—is a sweet must. Also try the breakfast burrito or avocado toast with a splash of chili oil for something savory.

Local Tip: It’s walk-in only and gets busy fast, so arrive early (or closer to noon for a late breakfast after the rush). Order your coffee iced—even in October—it’s tradition here.

• Price Range: $–$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.4/5 on Yelp)
  📍 Location: 17 Mayhew Lane, Edgartown, MA

14. The Red Cat Kitchen – Playful Plates & Big Flavor in Oak Bluffs

Funky, bold, and packed with personality, The Red Cat Kitchen is a standout on Oak Bluffs’ dining strip. With a handwritten chalkboard menu and an ever-changing lineup of fresh island ingredients, it’s a chef-driven experience where no two visits are the same. Think soulful food, funky décor, and some of the most exciting flavors on the Vineyard.

Specialty: The lobster tacos are wildly popular, and their sticky ribs come with finger-licking spice and sweetness. Expect surprises: chef specials are a nightly highlight.

Local Tip: There’s no printed menu, so come ready to trust the vibe and go with the flow. Reservations recommended, especially in peak season—it’s tiny and fills fast.

• Price Range: $$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 6 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs

15. The Terrace at The Charlotte Inn – Garden Elegance & French Flair

For classic fine dining with timeless charm, The Terrace is an island gem hidden in plain sight. Located at The Charlotte Inn, this Edgartown restaurant feels like stepping into a 19th-century European manor—polished service, romantic lighting, and beautifully plated French-American cuisine served in a garden courtyard or elegant salon.

Specialty: The duck à l’orange and lobster bisque are refined and rich, and the soufflé desserts are a rare island indulgence. The chef’s tasting menu is a must if you’re feeling celebratory.

Local Tip: This is jacket-friendly territory. Make it a slow, multi-course night—The Terrace is best enjoyed unrushed. Order a classic cocktail and take your time.

• Price Range: $$$$
• Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.7/5 on Google)
  📍 Location: 27 South Summer Street, Edgartown, MA

With this full list of 15 unforgettable Martha’s Vineyard dining experiences, you’re ready to eat your way across the island—from breezy harbor views and comfort classics to refined multi-course meals that linger in your memory (and your camera roll).