Dog-Friendly Restaurants on Martha's Vineyard: Where to Eat with Your Pup

Restaurants on Martha's Vineyard That Welcome Dogs

Let’s get real: Martha’s Vineyard isn’t exactly rolling out the red carpet for our four-legged friends when it comes to dining out. In fact, many towns on the island—especially Edgartown—have policies that make it tough to find restaurants with dog-friendly outdoor spaces. Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs also lean more pet-cautious than pet-friendly, with only a handful of exceptions.

But don’t worry, dog lovers! There are a few standout spots where you can enjoy great food, soak up island vibes, and bring your pup along for the adventure. Whether you're sipping craft beer, snacking on seafood, or chilling under string lights, these six restaurants will make both you and your dog feel right at home. Plus, we’ve thrown in a local clambake hack and a dog-friendly beach tip for the ultimate Vineyard day with your furry best friend.

Nomans – Island Chill with Pup Appeal

This relaxed outdoor hotspot in Oak Bluffs is one of the most dog-friendly joints on the entire island. Noman’s is less of a traditional restaurant and more of a beachy backyard party—complete with lawn games, picnic tables, and a rotating selection of food truck-style bites. Dogs are not only allowed; they’re welcomed with open arms and fresh water bowls.

Specialty: The menu changes often, but you can count on lobster rolls, smash burgers, tacos, and summery cocktails to keep you coming back.

Local Tip: Bring a blanket and sprawl out on the lawn while your pup mingles with the locals. It’s a social scene—for both humans and dogs.

Location: 15 Island Inn Rd, Oak Bluffs

Chilmark Tavern – Upscale & Unexpectedly Pet-Friendly

Out in the quieter Up-Island village of Chilmark, Chilmark Tavern is known for its refined menu and community spirit. Though technically an indoor restaurant, the tavern sometimes offers limited outdoor seating where dogs are allowed—especially on quieter nights.

Specialty: Think handmade pastas, inventive veggie dishes, and seasonal seafood. The local scallop risotto is legendary.

Local Tip: This is a BYOB spot, so bring your favorite chilled wine or craft beer for a perfect laid-back evening.

Location: 9 State Rd, Chilmark

Bad Martha Farmer's Brewery – Pints and Pups

Bad Martha’s in Edgartown is the ultimate pup-friendly hangout for craft beer lovers. The brewery’s large beer garden is dog-friendly and shaded, with plenty of space for pups to stretch out while you sample flights of locally brewed beer.

Specialty: Seasonal brews like the Martha’s Vineyard Ale and Shark Bite IPA pair perfectly with their locally sourced snack plates.

Local Tip: They sometimes host dog-themed events and pop-ups, so keep an eye on their calendar during the summer months.

Location: 270 Upper Main St, Edgartown

Nancy's – Seaside Bites with a Side of Dog Love

A true Oak Bluffs classic, Nancy’s sits right on the harbor and is one of the only eateries in town where dogs are allowed on the outer deck. Grab some seafood from the takeout window and find a seat with your pup to enjoy waterfront views and classic Vineyard energy.

Specialty: Fried clams, lobster rolls, and the iconic Dirty Banana cocktail from Donovan’s tiki bar.

Local Tip: Don’t miss the harbor sunset—it’s one of the best places to catch it with a drink in hand and your dog at your side.

Location: 29 Lake Ave, Oak Bluffs

El Barco – Tacos & Tequila with a Dog-Friendly Deck

El Barco is a newer addition to the Oak Bluffs food scene and has quickly become a local fave thanks to its fresh Mexican street food and bold, colorful décor. Their outdoor patio is dog-friendly and super laid-back.

Specialty: Street tacos, esquites (Mexican street corn salad), and a tequila list that’ll make your head spin—in a good way.

Local Tip: Go for the birria tacos and a spicy mango margarita, then chill with your pup under the lights.

Location: 6 Union St, Vineyard Haven

The Black Dog Tavern – Classic Vineyard with a Side of Dog Tolerance

A true island icon, The Black Dog Tavern in Vineyard Haven has a strict no-dogs-inside policy, but you can usually sit on the adjacent benches or grass outside with your takeout meal and pup. There's also a dog bowl near the outdoor shop area—clearly, they know their brand.

Specialty: Clam chowder, hearty breakfasts, and the famous “Black Dog” branded everything.

Local Tip: Order takeout and head over to the beach across the road—it’s not the most dog-friendly beach officially, but many folks relax there with leashed dogs and coffee in hand.

Location: 20 Beach St, Vineyard Haven

Scottish Bakehouse – Farm-Fresh, Dog-Friendly, & Locally Loved

This Up-Island bakery is one of the most truly dog-welcoming places on the Vineyard. Scottish Bakehouse has shaded outdoor picnic tables and a relaxed vibe that makes it a favorite for locals (and their dogs) picking up breakfast or lunch.

Specialty: Fresh-baked pastries, egg sandwiches, organic salads, and daily vegan/gluten-free options.

Local Tip: Bring a blanket and stretch out in the grassy area nearby. The Bakehouse is also right off one of the bike trails if you’re exploring the island on two wheels with your dog in tow.

Location: 977 State Rd, Vineyard Haven

Bonus Tip: Beach Clambake with Your Pup

If the dining scene feels too restrictive, consider grabbing a clambake dinner to-go from The Net Result (in Vineyard Haven) and heading to a dog-friendly beach. One solid option is East Chop Beach (just right of where Oak Bluffs Harbor begins)—it's usually quiet, low-key, and welcoming to dogs.

Unpack your feast, let your pup dig in the sand, and toast to a perfect island evening with salty air and fresh seafood. That’s Vineyard magic.

Though Martha’s Vineyard may not be the most dog-forward island when it comes to dining, with a little planning and these local favorites, you and your furry friend can still savor the best flavors of the island—together. Stay wild, eat well, and wag often.