Nantucket vs. Martha's Vineyard: Which Island Is Better for a Weekend Getaway?
Planning a weekend escape from the mainland and torn between Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard? You’re not alone. For many Massachusetts locals and curious out-of-towners, choosing between these two classic Cape islands can be tricky. Each has its own charm, pace, and personality. So which one should you pick for your next weekend getaway?
Let’s break it down by what matters most—things to do, ease of getting around, vibes, and costs.
🎡 Things to Do: Vineyard Wins on Variety
Martha’s Vineyard is bigger—nearly double the size of Nantucket—and it shows in the range of activities. From exploring the whimsical gingerbread cottages in Oak Bluffs to hiking in Manuel F. Correllus State Forest, there’s plenty of elbow room and a good mix of nature and culture. You can sip Bloody Marys at The Lookout, browse boutique shops, or just lose yourself beach-hopping around the island.
Nantucket, on the other hand, is more compact and feels like an idyllic, storybook New England village frozen in time. The Whaling Museum is a standout, and Brant Point Lighthouse is Insta-famous. There’s a distinct sense of “getting away from it all” here—but fewer activities overall.
🧭 Verdict: If you want more to do, especially outdoors, go with Martha’s Vineyard. If you want a quieter, less packed weekend, Nantucket has charm in spades.
🚴♀️ Getting Around: Both Are Car-Free Friendly (With Caveats)
Nantucket is very walkable and has an excellent network of bike paths. You can easily rent a bike and see the entire island without needing a car. Great if you're planning to go slow and soak in the scenery.
Martha’s Vineyard might look daunting at first due to its size, but its public bus system is solid. You don’t need a car—buses are cheap, frequent, and can even carry your bike. That said, getting between towns takes longer than on compact Nantucket.
🚍 Verdict: Both are car-optional. Prefer compact and bike-friendly? Go Nantucket. Want a larger island but still avoid driving? Vineyard’s buses and bike-friendliness have you covered.
🏖️ Island Vibes: Choose Your Energy
Nantucket leans toward a more exclusive, upscale, and quiet vibe. It feels like a true outpost—some say a “refined escape” with cobblestone streets and classic shingle-style architecture. You’ll find fewer crowds, pricier menus, and a tight-knit atmosphere.
Martha’s Vineyard is more vibrant and diverse. Oak Bluffs is lively, with music, restaurants, and a youthful energy. Edgartown brings the posh charm. There’s a “something for everyone” feel—from families to college friends to solo travelers.
🌊 Verdict: If you’re looking for peace and polished beauty, Nantucket is it. If you want a mix of beach town buzz and quiet corners, Martha’s Vineyard delivers.
💰 Costs: Budget Check
Nantucket is notoriously expensive—accommodation, dining, even bike rentals can feel like a splurge. That exclusivity comes with a price tag.
Martha’s Vineyard, while not cheap, is generally more budget-friendly. More lodging options, more casual dining spots, and less sticker shock overall.
💵 Verdict: If budget is a factor, Martha’s Vineyard gives you more room to breathe.
🛳️ Getting There: Logistics Matter
Ferries to Martha’s Vineyard typically depart from Woods Hole, and you can often get a same-day spot during off-peak weekends. There's also the bonus that Woods Hole is a charming seaside town worth exploring.
Ferries to Nantucket usually leave from Hyannis and are often sold out on weekends during summer. Flying is an option too, but comes at a cost.
🧭 Verdict: For easier and often quicker access, Martha’s Vineyard wins.
🚲 A Note on Biking
Both islands offer great cycling, but Nantucket has better bike path infrastructure. If you’re planning a weekend on two wheels, it’s smoother and easier to do a full loop there.
Martha’s Vineyard has gorgeous bike trails, but the connectivity between major towns could be better—expect a mix of dedicated paths and roadside riding.
🏆 So... Which One Should You Pick?
Choose Martha’s Vineyard if you want:
- A mix of beach, hikes, shopping, and dining
- Public transportation or biking without needing a car
- A more dynamic and social weekend
- A slightly more budget-friendly trip
Choose Nantucket if you want:
- A quieter, refined island atmosphere
- Great biking infrastructure
- A smaller, more walkable experience
- A feeling of being “somewhere else entirely”
The Bottom Line for Your Island Getaway
Both islands are beautiful, unique, and well worth a visit. If it’s your first island getaway past the Cape, Martha’s Vineyard is probably the better all-around choice. But if you’re looking to slow down, splurge a bit, and feel totally off-grid (without being off-luxury), Nantucket is an unforgettable escape.
Either way? You can’t go wrong. Just book that ferry early and bring your bike or walking shoes.
More from
North American Islands
Category
