Life on Nantucket: A Tale of Two Islands
Nantucket—just saying the name evokes sailboats, sandy lanes, and ice cream cones eaten barefoot by the harbor. But while the summer snapshots sell the dream, year-round life on this storied island is far more layered than most outsiders imagine.
Let’s take a deep dive into what it really means to live on Nantucket—from the luxe summer buzz to the quiet, wind-whipped winters.
The Summer Surge: Crowds, Cash, and Hustle Culture
From late May through Labor Day, Nantucket bursts to life. The sleepy population of 14,000 explodes to over 80,000 on peak weekends, with visitors arriving by ferry, puddle jumper, or private jet. Beach towels and Bentley sightings become equally common.
Downtown turns into a runway of seersucker suits and sunhats. Shops brim with premium brands, and restaurants serve up lobster rolls with champagne pairings. Everyone’s here to soak up the charm—with a side of status.
Meanwhile, the island’s seasonal workforce shifts into overdrive. Locals joke, “If you’ve only got two jobs, you’re slacking.” It’s not uncommon to see someone serve brunch, rent bikes in the afternoon, then bartend until midnight.
Finding a place to sleep is half the battle. Affordable housing is a unicorn. Most workers crash in bunk-style staff housing—if they’re lucky. Rentals skyrocket, often topping $20,000 a week. One local described it as: “If you're not rich, you better be resourceful.”
The Off-Season: Quiet, Cold, and Kindred Spirits
Once September ends and the last beach towels are packed away, Nantucket changes pace dramatically.
Shops close. Streets empty out. The calendar slows. What remains is a skeleton crew of hardy year-rounders who keep the island running through the long, windswept winter.
A former winter visitor recalled it as, “A ghost town with salt in its bones.” For some, the silence is soothing. For others, it’s a slow burn of isolation.
Entertainment options shrink to bonfires, books, or bundled-up walks along the shore. With limited off-season transport, many locals stock up on essentials before winter storms roll in—because when the fog hits, you're not going anywhere.
But in that solitude comes community. There’s a deep sense of looking out for one another. As one resident said, “Everyone’s got your back when it counts—it’s the island way.”
A Landscape of Contrasts: Legacy Names and New Faces
Historically, Nantucket is home to some of America’s oldest money—families who trace their lineage back to whaling ships and Quaker settlements. Their names live on through street signs, landmarks, and old sea tales passed down through generations.
Today, the island’s story has grown more diverse. Seasonal and permanent workers from El Salvador, Jamaica, and parts of Asia now form the backbone of Nantucket’s hospitality, construction, and service industries.
As one long-time visitor put it: “It’s a blend of Rolexes and work boots. You’ll find both at the same coffee shop.”
And that’s part of Nantucket’s charm—the meeting of worlds. But not without its tensions. The housing crisis impacts working families the hardest, and many locals are squeezed out of their own island.
Getting Around: Plan Ahead or Pay Big
Living on Nantucket means dealing with the realities of island logistics. Ferries are lifelines. Flights are often canceled due to fog. And bringing a car onto the island can cost more than a plane ticket.
Yes, there are discounts for residents, but everything from groceries to furniture is marked up. “A gallon of milk here could buy you dinner on the mainland,” one islander joked.
Still, Nantucket is wonderfully walkable and bike-friendly. The absence of highways, traffic lights, and city noise is a refreshing throwback. There’s even a small but efficient bus system that connects the island’s major areas.
Still Magical: Beaches, Bonfires, and Unwritten Rules
Even with the wealth disparity and winter blues, the island retains an undeniable magic. Starlit beaches, foggy mornings, and clapboard houses bursting with hydrangeas—it’s postcard perfection with a twist of real life.
While vacationers may think of it as a getaway, longtime residents speak with reverence about the island’s soul. “It’s not just where I live—it’s who I’ve become,” one said.
And the traditions run deep. From the famous Figawi race to the Daffodil Festival, the calendar is dotted with community-driven events that bring everyone together—tourists, transplants, and old-timers alike.
Presidents vacation here. Authors write about it. And every local seems to have at least one celebrity story they’re too cool to tell. The island is just remote enough that it keeps its mystique, but familiar enough to feel like home—if you can afford it.
So… Should You Move to Nantucket?
If you’re dreaming of a quiet, coastal life with rugged beauty and small-town bonds, Nantucket might just steal your heart. But know this—it’s not easy living.
You’ll battle ferry delays, insane housing costs, and frigid winters. You’ll work hard. You’ll live simply. You might even grow to love that the gas stations close by 8 PM.
But if the idea of biking past wild roses on your way to work, watching seals play in the surf, and waving to every passerby on Main Street sounds like your speed—Nantucket might be calling your name.
Just don’t expect to blend in right away. As they say on the island: “If you weren’t born here, you’re ‘from away’—no matter how long you stay.”
More from
North American Islands
Category
